the gapanese invasion is nigh!

"pinakamaganda ka nga sa buong kapuluan, pero latina na naman ang magwawagi ng korona at sash sa miss world! racism ba ito? lupasay!"

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

blunder in gabriel garcia marquez’ i only came to use the phone


In the terrifying story I Only Came to Use the Phone, a philosophical question emerged: is it the husband or the wife who was at fault?
Personal bias served as the main conflict in the story. With this, I mean that an individual’s biased opinion regarding another individual could lead to the development of an incorrect judgment, which then creates an error in opinion. Using this as basis, I think it is Maria’s husband and not she who was guilty of Maria’s subsequent, mad-like decision never to leave the mental hospital. He had a biased opinion against his wife, which led to his error in opinion and judgment.
Maria’s husband was biased against her actions since the very beginning. When Maria failed to return home, he immediately concluded she had left again as she had previously done to him as well as to other men before him. He was at fault since he did not even thought that she must have met some trouble along the road, which indeed was what happened when her car broke down in the Monegros Desert. Instead of worrying about a possible disaster that must have befallen her, he believed that she just ran off with a new man. When Maria finally got the chance to contact her husband for her real condition and whereabouts, he went to the mental hospital and spoke to the doctor, who confessed that Maria had a mental illness. Here, the husband again wrongly assumed that there must be some truth since Maria was behaving rather oddly. Upon deciding that she should stay longer in the hospital instead of being freed, he had judged against his wife.
Our idea of truth gets distorted because of the human error of personal bias. Our distance from truth even contributes to this distortion, because we can only approximate truth but never reach it. As a result of this farness and personal subjectivity, we have different ways of seeing truth. Maria says the truth that she was not crazy, but her husband has his own brand of truth based on the accounts in which Maria manifested her seeming madness.
This is a flaw on the husband’s part because his manner of philosophy was lazy and incomplete. He philosophized lazily because he believed truth to come only from an authority, such as the mental hospital expert. Against the truth of a professional, that of Maria’s would not carry weight, so her husband wrongly assumed she was crazy. Also, he philosophized incompletely because he did not consider all sides of possibilities. Her past actions made him believe she had ran off again, while it was possible too that she might have met some trouble along the way. He did not even see through her enraged protestations when she could not convince him that she was not crazy. Instead, he decided that her agitated behavior was characteristic of the mental illness she was suffering from.
Being at fault, the husband has caused the ruin of Maria’s life when she decided to stay in the mental hospital as a result of his error in opinion and judgment. It may be seen as a devastating decision on the part of Maria, but it may actually be a right one, especially that no one believed the truth about her sound mentality.

9 comments:

  1. Anonymous5:03 PM

    i have not read the story but it sounds like she was a victim of her past.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey, I am writing a post about this story too. But I can't find a link to read it online. Do you know where I can find it?
    Thank you so much.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous2:14 PM

    Samsungs true rival certainly being is interesting when you hear
    what people have to say about these two leading end tablets.
    A whole host of image enhancing features is provided as standard which allows users
    to manipulate and edit images and videos, including autofocus, touch-focus, face & smile detection as
    well as geo-tagging which functions based on GPS. They
    are Vodafone, Virgin, T-Mobile, Orange, O2 and Three.


    Also visit my website; samsung galaxy tab 2

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous5:59 PM

    Invest the money you saved into some nice accessories. A Canon
    Powershot s60 software also comes either for Microsoft Windows operating software or for the Mac
    operating software, so this means whatever operating software you use,
    you can be sure that your Canon Powershot s60 digital camera will work great for you.
    re photographing flowers, a captivating sunset, or your friends at the
    park, you can be confident that you.

    Also visit my page; canon 6d review

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous6:57 PM

    A fast and practical netbook that may be for the more.
    The NP-NF310 retails around $350 and features
    an ultra fast start-up speed (under 3 seconds) and a 9+ hour battery life.

    With built-in Adobe Flash support and a great browser, my children
    have complete access to their documents, calendars, email, and entertainment.


    my page; samsung chromebook review

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous7:24 PM

    Just go and browse through some serviceed online websites
    and acquisition out the deals of your best with just few simple clicks.
    The specifications are sure to attract every gadget geek, but
    anyone who has the opportunity to get their hands on the Play -
    Book will never want to part ways with it. Apple
    products include the Iphones, Ipads and Ipods
    all at competitive prices.

    Take a look at my blog ... playbook review

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous8:11 PM

    You see people passing time by checking on friends, catching up on texts or e-mail or playing a video game oblivious to
    what is happening around. Altogether, one will find it easy to edit files, upload
    them and share them with others, as well as take either
    single images and look at them for instant review on the 480 by 360 screen.

    Moreover, it has been observed that Apple's i - Phone apps access personal data without asking user's permission the way
    it should be.

    Feel free to surf to my homepage: samsung galaxy s4

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous2:03 AM

    Only use your AC or Heater if it is absolutely necessary. Recent times have noticed a massive increase the realm of computerized thermostats, nest looks to
    turn bradenton surrounding. Look for bargains, when buying expensive things that you need.



    Here is my page nest thermostat

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous7:00 PM

    Providing great deals for the customers and full service.
    You can't help but appreciate the Apple Macbook series of notebooks, especially the MA897LL A. The most recent Thunderbolt technology creates an extraordinary functionality in terms of the transferring as well as sharing of network from one peripheral device to the other.

    Look into my homepage; mac book pro

    ReplyDelete